Tomorrow's tech news, today's hangover.

The Extra Correct Answer

Three hundred and ninety-seven and a half out of four hundred. That is not a score you can fold up very small.

A South Korean tax-accountancy candidate admitted using a microcamera, a phone and generative AI to cheat. In the first round he got one question wrong out of 160. The extraordinary score aroused suspicion. What interests me is the surplus. All those correct answers, reporting for duty long after a man might have had enough to pass.

I like getting my money’s worth. This makes me a bad audience for a sermon about excess. Tell me that a machine can help with one problem and I want to know about the next problem. I don’t want a second machine. I don’t even particularly want a second problem. But if the help is already there, leaving it unused feels like buying a ticket and getting off the train before my stop. Somebody has had something out of me.

It is a peculiar appetite because it can continue without much pleasure. The next answer needn’t be a wonderful answer. It is simply available. There is a space on the sheet. The answer fits the space. A small transaction can be completed, and then another. You don’t have to stand up halfway through and announce that mere employment is beneath you and you intend to astonish the nation. An unnecessary result can be assembled out of perfectly ordinary little additions.

That is what makes a passing mark so difficult to admire. It has a job to do, and then it wants to go home. There is something almost insulting about its lack of ambition. You’ve passed. Yes, but how well? Well enough. Well enough for what? For the thing you came here to do. This conversation could be over in ten seconds if anybody would let it.

A score has the advantage of looking like a complete instruction. Four hundred is more than three hundred. The pencil understands what to do. Enough, on the other hand, starts asking questions about the room, the other candidates, the people who will examine the results, the sort of attention you can stand. Suddenly you need to know quite a lot about things that aren’t on the paper. It is irritating. You went to considerable trouble to acquire the answers and now somebody wants judgment as well.

With a test, at least the upper limit is printed. You can finish the whole damned thing. There is a purity to that which I find hard to dislike. No further questions. No extra task tucked into a cheerful email. Nothing left on the table. An exam is a miserable thing, but the possibility of reaching its actual end gives it an advantage over most paid work.

Then a score like 397.5 comes along and makes completion look like an extravagance.

The arithmetic is not the interesting part. I’m interested in the moment when another correct answer ceases to be useful and remains correct. There is no visible damage to the answer. You can hold it up to the light. Nothing wrong with it. It hasn’t become a false answer or a bad answer. It is good material for a result you may not want. This offends the part of me that saves the extra screw after assembling a shelf. Surely a good thing must be good for something. Surely there is a way to get full value out of it.

And there sits the next question, not yet answered.

I would have less trouble with a temptation that looked expensive. A bigger house has walls. A second dessert arrives on a plate. But an extra correct answer is almost weightless. You don’t have to carry it back to the car. It doesn’t seem to have taken anything from you. It improves the number. To refuse it, you have to make a little case against improvement, and improvement has already hired all the respectable words.

Ambition. Thoroughness. Excellence. Try telling those three to wait outside. They have certificates. They have come early. Restraint is still looking for the building.

This is where my admiration for stopping runs into practical difficulties. I can admire it comfortably after someone else has failed to do it. From there the exact point to stop looks beautifully clear. Beforehand, it is mixed in with cowardice, laziness, sensible caution and the ordinary wish to be finished. They all wear the same coat. You can’t just announce that you’re a man who knows when to stop. So is every man who has quit five minutes too soon.

Nor is there a dependable little score called inconspicuous. A lower mark is not an invisibility cloak. There are other people in the room, and they have eyes, suspicions, procedures, bad moods. This is an annoying defect in the fantasy of the tidy cheat. He wants to solve the paper and then solve the audience. The audience keeps moving.

I don’t want an extra examination in restraint. Imagine having to sit that one after everything else. A desk, a clock, a sheet full of correct answers. Instructions: use only what you require. Candidates may not ask what they require. Results will be assessed by people whose expectations have not been supplied. The examination ends when you say it ends, and saying so is part of the examination.

I would complain about the wording. I would want a sample paper. Above all, I would want to know the highest possible mark for doing just enough.


Source: South Korea’s top scorer in tax accountancy exam admits cheating