The glass is half-empty, the ashtray is half-full, and the internet is, as always, completely out of its goddamn mind. Iâm staring at a headline that says, âAI doesnât know what an orgasm sounds like.â
And I think, hell, most men Iâve met donât either. So maybe the machines arenât so far behind after all.
I take a drag from my cigarette and a pull from the bourbon. The smoke and the liquor have a little party in my lungs. Itâs a real party, a human one. Messy. Probably carcinogenic. But real. Thatâs more than you can say for the latest brilliant idea coughed up by the algorithm factories.
So Amazonâs Audible and the rest of the tech behemoths want to have robots read us bedtime stories. Theyâre rolling out AI-generated voices to narrate audiobooks. They say itâs about giving more authors a chance, about âlowering the barrier to entry.â Thatâs the kind of sanitized corporate poetry that always means one thing: we found a cheaper way to do it and weâre going to fire a lot of people.
Every time one of these companies talks about âaccessibilityâ or âdemocratization,â you should check your wallet. Theyâre not building a library of Alexandria for the masses. Theyâre building a digital slum, a content favela stacked high with cheap, mass-produced audio slurry. Itâs the literary equivalent of a fast-food burger. Sure, it fills a hole, but you feel sick afterwards and you know, deep down in your gut, that it wasnât really food.
This actress, Annabelle Tudor, she hit the nail right on the head. Sheâs narrated 48 books. Sheâs breathed life into words, probably while fighting off a cold or worrying about rent. Sheâs done the work. And she says the AI canât do a raunchy sex scene. It doesnât know the sound of an orgasm. Or a birth.
Of course it doesnât. How could it? An orgasm isnât a data point. Itâs not a waveform you can just replicate. Itâs a loss of control. Itâs ugly and beautiful and embarrassing and divine. Itâs the sound of a nervous system getting fried by its own wiring. Itâs the most un-robotic thing there is.
I can just picture the board meeting. A dozen guys in identical grey fleeces, sipping artisanal coffee. âOkay, Johnson, on the orgasm module. Whatâs the progress?â âWell, sir, weâve analyzed 10,000 hours of audio. Weâve found the optimal frequency is between 250 and 500 Hz, with a decibel spike at the 4.7-second mark. Weâre calling it Pleasure Synthesis 4.0.â âExcellent. Ship it.â
And what youâll get is the sound of a Speak & Spell falling down a flight of stairs. Youâll get a sound so sterile, so perfectly modulated, itâll make you want to take a vow of celibacy.
This isnât about sex scenes. Itâs about everything. Itâs about the catch in the throat when a character is about to break. Itâs the sound of a genuine laugh, not a pre-programmed âha-ha.wavâ. Itâs the subtle shift in tone that tells you a character is lying. Itâs the goddamn soul of the thing.
A human narrator spends days, weeks, with a book. They live with it. They understand the characters, the rhythm, the heart of the story. They take a drag from their own cigarette, pour their own damn drink, and they channel all that messy, broken, beautiful life experience into their voice. They give you a piece of themselves.
The AI gives you nothing. Itâs a void. A parrot squawking back patterns itâs been fed. It has no life experience. Itâs never been drunk. Itâs never been heartbroken. Itâs never stared at a ceiling at 4 a.m. wondering where it all went wrong. It has no story of its own, so how the hell can it tell you someone elseâs?
The suits will tell you itâs âgood enough.â Thatâs the mantra of the modern age. Good enough. Donât strive for greatness, donât pay for artistry. Just churn out something thatâs⊠adequate. Something that fills the silence while youâre jogging or doing the dishes. Theyâre banking on the fact that most people wonât notice, or wonât care. And the sad, ugly truth is, they might be right. Weâre a culture drowning in âgood enough.â
Then thereâs the next grimy step in this little dance: voice cloning. Theyâre offering to let narrators create digital dupes of themselves. âExpand their production capabilities,â the corporate pamphlet says. What it means is, âSell us your voice, your soul, your unique brand, and weâll turn you into a piece of software. Weâll pay you once, a pittance, and then your ghost can work for us, 24/7, for eternity, with no bathroom breaks.â
Imagine that. You spend a lifetime honing your craft, developing a voice that people recognize and trust. And then you sell it off to be used to narrate anything. Your rich, thoughtful baritone could be used to read a trashy vampire romance, the terms and conditions for a new app, or a manual on how to assemble Swedish furniture. Your voice, the thing that is uniquely you, becomes a mass-produced robot sound that people get sick of. You become the new Comic Sans.
Another shot of bourbon. It bites back. Good. Reminds me Iâm alive.
The real danger here isn’t just that some poor actor in Melbourne or Sydney loses a gig. The danger is that we forget what quality is. We cheapen the whole damn enterprise. We get so used to the synthetic taste that we forget what real food tastes like. Storytelling is one of the oldest human traditions. Weâve been doing it since we were huddled around fires, scared of the things in the dark. A voice in the night, telling you a taleâitâs an intimate, primal connection.
Trying to replace that with a machine is a âfoolish move,â as one of the guys in the article says. But these companies are run by fools. Theyâre fools with billions of dollars and a messianic belief in their own code. They donât understand value, only price. They see a human beingâan artistâand all they can think is, âHow can we automate this? How can we get this pesky, expensive meat-sack out of the equation?â
And the kicker is, theyâll probably succeed for a while. Theyâll flood Audible and Spotify with tens of thousands of these audio-zombies. People will consume them. Sales figures will go up. Some guy in a boardroom will get a huge bonus. And something small but important will die. The space for real art will shrink just a little bit more, crowded out by the cheap and the easy.
So can we just listen to people instead of robots?
Itâs a nice thought. A hopeful one. But hope is a dangerous thing. Itâs like a good woman or a full bottleâit never lasts as long as you think it will. In the end, it always comes down to the money. And thereâs no money in being human. Not anymore. The profit is in the imitation.
I stub out my cigarette. The room is quiet except for the hum of the old machine I write this garbage on. I think about all the voices Iâve loved in my life. The raspy voice of an old bartender telling a dirty joke. The soft voice of a woman in the dark. The angry voice of a poet spitting truth from a stage. None of them were perfect. All of them were real.
Let the robots have their ones and zeros. Let them calculate their perfect, soulless orgasms. Iâll take the messy, flawed, drunken, beautiful, human noise every single time. Itâs the only story worth hearing.
Time for another drink.
-H.C.